17 September 2011

Guilt

In 2003 I was activated from as an Army Reservist for the initial invasion of Iraq.  My unit did not go anywhere, we ended up staying stateside and running SRP sites, resetting equipment, etc.

For years I felt incredibly guilty about not being able to prove myself by serving in a war zone.  I finished college, signed another contract, went to OCS, Infantry Basic Officer Leaders Course, Ranger School, Airborne School, the Army Marksmanship Squad Designated Marksmen and CQB train the trainer courses, the Anti Armor Leaders Course, and even Sniper Employment Officer.  And finally, six years after my mobilization got to go to Iraq as a Platoon Leader.

And we had two rounds fired at us the whole time.  Either I was doing something very right, or the enemy was simply not targeting us.  Considering we were rolling in less than 16 man "platoons" I really hope that we were doing something right.

But that experience ended way too quickly, and I was sent back stateside to handle the most difficult job of my career to date, handling the Rear Detachment.  I gained twenty pounds and caught pneumonia.  Four and a half months of "deployed" time which was really three months of "combat leadership" was way less than I was willing to do.  I didn't sign up to be a baby sitter, but that was the job I was given.

So after nine months of misery I headed off to the Captain's Career Course and volunteered to join a brigade already in eastern Afghanistan, right on the Af/Pak border.  So I graduate, dropping thirteen pounds in five months and managing to tear the crap out of my left shoulder.  I make it to my new unit, abuse my rank ruthlessly to speed through the inprocessing paperwork and SRP shuffle and less than a month from signing in am on a plane across the pond to join my unit.

And I get sent to the Special Troops Battalion to do staff time.  No leadership position, not surrounded by Infantrymen, just replacing another unlucky Infantry Captain who did two years in the job I'm now filling before he got a shot at Company Command. 

So kids, the sad truth is this, if you choose a life of service you don't get much of a choice as to how that service will play out.  The hardest part about my particular military career is that, aside from a few AK rounds and a 1000 pound VBIED going off 100 meters away, ten year of wartime service has really been "go here, do this, do that, go there." 

Some days I feel guilty that I'm still alive when others aren't.  I don't ever want to see another toddler with a concerned look on his face while his 20 year old mother balls her eyes out.  I don't want to have to give condolences to grieving family members.  I'll do it if it is my duty, but that isn't what I had in mind when I signed on the dotted line.  I don't want to say goodbye to another hero as his family debates when to take him off life support.

Still to this day I feel guilty that I haven't done enough.  I've volunteered for everything that's come down the pipe, I've never turned down an assignment.  I've pushed and pushed to get into the fight.  And it has gotten me nowhere.  A companies worth of Soldiers have died not 100 miles from me in the last eight weeks and I couldn't do a blessed thing to prevent it.

“The worst pain a man can suffer: to have insight into much and power over nothing”. Herodotus.
 
I'll continue to do my duty.  I signed my name and entered into the contract of my own free will.  To give anything less would be an affront to all that I hold dear.  But I'll probably feel guilty for a while yet.  In my head I know I'm not God and cannot hold power over who lives and who dies.  But in my heart, I grieve that I couldn't save them.

11 comments:

Brock Townsend said...

You are a man of honor and as such, do the best you can, you cannot do more.

http://www.namsouth.com/viewtopic.php?t=2832&highlight=letter
Duty, then, is the sublimest word in our language. Do your duty in all things like the old Puritan. You cannot do more; you should never wish to do less. Never let your mother or me wear one gray hair for any lack of duty on your part.

John Robert Mallernee said...

Sir:

I know exactly where you're coming from, for I too, had the frustration of being a REMP in the rear with the gear, and being shot at, but not allowed to return fire.

I was never an ossifer, nor was I really a very competent soldier, though I did try my level best.

I wasn't even supposed to be in the Army, for I was classified "IV-F" by the draft board.

But, I wrote a letter to President Johnson requesting that my classification be changed to "I-A", pointing out that Viet Nam was an unpopular war, with lots of guys burning their draft cards or deserting the ranks.

So, my classification got changed, but I still couldn't enlist.

I really wanted to be in the United States Marine Corps, but it never happened.

So, I volunteered for the draft, which automatically put me in the United States Army.

After barely making it through Basic Combat Training, I went to Signal School at Fort Gordon, Georgia to learn Field Radio Relay and Carrier Equipment Repair (MOS 31 L 20).

That was MANY years ago, and neither the equipment nor the MOS exists today, and several of the units I served in have been deactivated.

Despite the fact that I tried really hard, I barely made it through Signal School, failing the final exam.

I had passed the written portion of the test, but flunked the practical exam by two questions.

So, they kept me there an additional two weeks and then asked me two ridiculously easy questions.

That's how I got my MOS!

After serving in Germany, I reenlisted to go to Viet Nam, where my first assignment was the Phu Lam Signal Battalion in Saigon.

Yep, there I was, in the lap of luxury, and embarrassed that one day, I would return to the states and tell folks I spent my war in comfortable Saigon.

So, against the advice of my Sergeant Major (whom I went to church with - - - we were both Mormon), I traded places with another guy and went to Dong Ha.

There, I sat behind a desk pushing a pencil as I watched tanks rolling out the gate to go fight, and on guard duty, I could watch the firefights in front of me.

So, I volunteered for the 101st Airborne, which gave me a little field time, though I was still in the Signal Corps with a critical Signal MOS that couldn't be changed to a combat MOS.

Yeah, they gave me a couple of medals, which look really impressive, but the truth is, I don't have any war stories to go along with them.

But, YOU - - - ?

Be GLAD you don't have to go get blown to bits!

You've got your wife and young'uns to think about.

They need you a whole bunch more than Arlington National Cemetery or Walter Reed Army Medical Center does.

You've already proved your valor by jumping out of airplanes and qualifying as a ranger.

And like you said, when you take that oath and cross that line, you must go where you're sent and do what you're told.

Thank you.

John Robert Mallernee
Armed Forces Retirement Home
Gulfport, Mississippi 39507

Ted Amadeus said...

Count your blessings!
After my 18th birthday, in the jobless, stagnating climate of 1983, I was reminded to register with selective service and figured I'd do them one better by signing up.
The Air Force said my vision wasn't good enough.
The Navy said I was too stupid.
The Army and Marines agreed I was too fat.
By the time I got all those excuses out of the way for them, they and SS told me I was too goddamn old!

Your military career went quite a bit further than mine.

Carry on, sir.

The Horse said...

Don't feel guilty there are plenty of us out in the big world that haven't even got the guts to sign up. You offered to put your life on the line for our freedom doesn't matter how you serve. The fact is you have served and continue to do so.

Remember the greatest armies on earth cannot march into battle without the support that goes on behind the lines. Your contribution has and still is making a difference.

Brigid said...

What you have done is so far above and beyond what the ordinary man will ever do, there is no need to ever feel guilty.

At one point in my life, my man was going to get out, he met my folks, we talked of time together, I saw a future that didn't involve him being thousands of miles away. He saw duty and went back into service. I don't know if I will ever see him again, he told me not to wait.

Heartbreaking yes, but I totally understand. There is a sense of honor in some people that rides above the petty wants of others.

Anonymous said...

as long as I have breath to pray, I will continue to ask God to keep you safe, and bring you home to your family. How he chooses to do that, or should he choose to do that, I have no control over. But I will keep praying for you. You just keep doing your best where ever you are, and it will all work out in the end. And maybe someday, you can help me weed the roses :)

AM said...

Thank you for the words of comfort. I know that what you say is true. Still there is a part of me that wishes I could do more.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Brock Townsend said...

Why do I have the good fortune to post after the one above......?

At any rate, I was thinking about Vietnam today, so I thought I should mention that if you 1049'd for doorgunner you could not be turned down. I was at USARV Headquarters in the replacement division and one person successfully did this even though the powers to be didn't want to lose him. I don't know about now, but something to think about. And then there was Dudley!:)
http://www.namsouth.com/viewtopic.php?t=270&highlight=dudley

SaysMindy said...

My brother is a Marine reservist and just got called to go over seas. He has had the same issue with feeling guilty because his buddy passed in Iraq and my brother had never gone over. From an outsider perspective, just know that even if someone never goes over, they are still a hero.

MrG's said...

I wanted to be a soldier since I could remember, my father was a soldier as was my grandfather, ete,ete. I went to JROTC in high school, did a year at North Georgia College with ROTC. Joined in 1985 when I ran out of money. Did 6 years with 5 years in Germany and the Persian Gulf Part 1. Got rifted when after we came back because we were told that people wanted their "peace dividend. My MOS was considered "Obsolete and balanced" so I couldn't reclassify and I couldn't get promoted. I finished my enlistment and became a civilian. My brother chose a better MOS than i did, he was Army Aviation and they expanded and became their own combat arm. It has been 20 plus years and my brother has several tours to Iraq and a tour to Astan and I still am a civilian. I wish more than once that I could still serve. I do things as a good citizen of the republic but I still have guilt that I am here and my brother is over there. I have served in combat and I wish I could do more. I live with what I call the shame of being in the rear and not actually fighting the evil that permeates our world. All I can do is fight the war of information and keep the truth out there. It isn't enough in my mind so I wrestle with it.
Keep doing what you are doing, Keep fighting the good fight.